Where finance and media intersect with reality.

Running on diesel fumes and other commodity crunch stories

shutterstock_2144732197

The diesel situation is dire. What policymakers seem to be missing is that it’s not just the market’s capacity to provide for today that is under stress. It’s also the market’s capacity to build inventories in the traditional inventory-building season.

I am on the run a lot until Saturday (in Poland), but I thought I would share a few insights from the market.

As one informed products expert tells me (currently unhindered by any conflicts other than being, err, part of the Blind Spot household):

The current low inventory situation is being caused by Russian diesel exports being reduced and by high natgas prices encouraging substitution towards diesel. This is all being compounded by low refinery rates from the Covid ear leading to refineries closing. All this means we are running on fumes. Market prices have done everything they can to keep the global system wet (market backwardation and huge refinery margins are max incentivised to make diesel). But it’s not enough. Without Russian barrels, we are going to struggle to build inventory at all this summer and next winter will be a disaster.

No EU buying strike can change this reality.

As I noted in Thursday’s Blind Spot wrap, the Poles seem especially oblivious to the long term consequences of all this. They are consumed with passion over the Ukraine situation and are not thinking logically at all as a result. I keep trying to explain to them that running your own economy to the ground and causing system-wide paralysis by the winter is not going to help anyone win any wars in the long run.

Separately, I will have the second part of my neon/helium story soon.

For now, I will share these stills that I have received from market sources depicting the scale of the explosion that occurred at Russia’s Amur LNG facility in January. Helium from this facility was supposed to be coming online about now easing shortages. I doubt very much it will be coming to Western markets any time soon. Even if this damage can be fixed, these facilities are in Russia.

The helium industry is talking the squeeze down, but they have every incentive to keep a lid on the story because any failure to deliver on contracts will break their grip on the market by creating a secondary market supplies headed to less strategic industries.

Relatedly, I mentioned in my Spotlight series that a source told me they had seen satellite images of the damage incurred at Qatar’s LNG facilities around this time and that it was pretty substantial. What I can share with TBS readers exclusively is that I have seen these images first hand now. Yes, they could be deepfakes I guess, but the sourcing pathway suggests otherwise.

Qatargas has still not formerly acknowledged this incident.

Here, meanwhile, is the before and after of the damage at the Mariupol’s steelworks where the bulk of the world’s neon was still produced up until the war broke out:

As I reported in my Spotlight on noble gases, these commodities are critical inputs for the semiconductor manufacturing process. With production from two of the main Ukrainian producers, Ingas (linked to Mariupol) and Cryoin in Odessa, now indefinitely suspended, security of future supply to Western markets is a real issue.

The main problem is that the market remains overly dependent on a handful of tier-one specialists – companies such as Linde, Air Liquide and Air Products – which prefer to engage in highly confidential long-term contracts. The lack of transparency has impeded the development of a spot market, where uncontracted sums can be sold at current market prices, and discouraged any semblance of natural price discovery or long-term breakeven rates.

Since nobody can be sure of current pricing, it’s hard to assess just how much noble gas supply there is. What we do know is, until the war in Ukraine broke out in 2014, up to 90 per cent of global neon supply – especially that headed to Western markets – was sourced from Ukraine. The bulk of this came from Mariupol facilities.
Metinvest, the company of Ukrainian billionaire Rinat Akhmetov, which owns Azovstal as well as the nearby Ilyich plant, has now said it is in the process of preparing lawsuits to the amount of $10 billion against Russia for the destruction of the two Mariupol facilities. This sum, however, will barely touch the second-order effects if semiconductor manufacturing becomes constrained because of neon shortages.
The same specialist companies also dominate the helium market. Would-be competitors and buyers claim that in many cases, the companies make agreements on loss-leading terms to capture broader gas supply business, preventing price discovery. (Linde and Air Products did not respond to emails asking for comment. A spokeswoman for Air Liquide said the company has no current exposure to Ukrainian or Russian neon supply issues.)
What little uncontracted supply exists is currently being quoted at five times the usual rate. This was confirmed to me by the CEO of South Africa-based Renergen, one of the few independent helium and natural gas producers bringing supply to market.
Since the helium market’s shortages predate the war in Ukraine by many years, it’s hard not to blame market structure for current circumstances.
In that context, it’s worth remembering that it was market tightness following the 1979 Iranian revolution that finally skewered the grip of the Seven Sisters cartel – the group of Western oil producers that dominated long-term contracting in the market – in a way that encouraged an active oil spot market to emerge.
More recently, the liquefied natural gas (LNG) market has seen a similar transformation on the back of market tightness caused by the 2011 Fukushima disaster and the post-Arab Spring decline in Egyptian production the same year. It moved gracefully from a “take or pay” type system indexed to oil prices to one in which spot cargoes now dominate, encouraging better price visibility and understanding of supply-side dynamics.
It’s very possible this could now happen in noble gases too.

 

The Daily Blind Spot newsletter

Latest posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *